American Idol Season 12
Friday, April 05, 2013 @ 7:22 PM | 0 comment(s)

To be honest, I had doubts about this year’s American Idol and its changes. Every time I saw their promotional teasers, I would be like, “Really? They’re doing that? I don’t think I’d see this.” The roster of the new judges is weird. Mariah Carey and Keith Urban are acceptable, but Nicki Minaj as a judge, really? I was baffled at that idea that I thought the producers of the show must be nuts and are planning to pull the show down. But I guess I stand corrected.

I’m not saying I already love Nicki with all my heart, but so far she’s proving to be a good judge. The only thing I don’t like about her is her way of expressing her opinions. When she gets frustrated she either walks out or threatens to walk out. Either way, it’s not good for the show. It doesn’t demonstrate professionalism and it’s definitely awkward for everyone else, even the audience. You just don’t do that in a live show. But I don’t know, maybe the drama and the shallow feud between her and Mariah are just stunts to attract more viewers.

Anyway, I’m not actually here to be a judge to the judges, but to lay down my favorite American Idol Season 12 contestants. I started doing this during Lee Dewyze’s time, and since then it has become a blogging tradition. This year, I only have five favorite contestants (one of them didn’t really make it to Top 10, but he’s just so fascinating he made it to my list).


Angela Miller. Angela is amazing, beautiful and quirky. What I love about her (including her wardrobe) is, of course, her voice: it’s whole (I don’t know the term) and doesn’t thin out when she takes on a high note; she doesn’t sound like a dying cockroach when she does her falsetto. Her voice is consistent. And I just love her even more when she sits behind her piano and go crazy with it – she’s like the female version of Colton Dixon, only she’s not really a rock star, but she is a star in her own right. (And her “Never Gone” cover was unquestionably a plus!)

Burnell Taylor. Unlike last year, the guy contestants this year are less stellar (and the girls are trampling on them every week), but an exception to that is Burnell. I didn’t notice him during his audition, but geez, that voice is just so good! I like his simplicity and that he doesn’t move around the stage a lot; he just stands there behind the microphone and moves his hands like a conductor and bam! He’s effortless. His voice is just a tone away from becoming a wrecked and annoying falsetto, but he just hit it right. And his nerdy look doesn’t hurt.

Kree Harrison. The first thing I noticed about Kree is her beauty – she’s just stunning. The features of her face are striking. And then she sang… and what the heck, she’s perfect. (And she has pretty shoes, if I may add.) If she just perform amazingly every week, she could actually – yo, yo dawg! – win this thing.

Charlie Askew. Charlie didn’t actually make it to Top 10, either because his Top 20 performance was all-out weird and scary so he lost some of his admirers or because he just doesn’t have enough admirers. But I’m one of them (but I couldn’t vote so screw me), and his cute eccentricity is what I like about him. I hope his weirdness will make him a star someday. Weird is special.

Amber Holcomb. One cool thing about Amber: she sings like she’s only sleeping. When she sings and belts out a ridiculous high note, it looks like she’s not doing anything. She remains cool, intact and smiling. She reminds me so much of Kurt (Chris Colfer) of Glee: they both sing like they’re not… singing. They’re aliens. It’s like Amber is from the Singing Planet of G-Clefs or the Do-Re-Mi World. She’s out-of-this-world. She would need a lot of supporters to – yo, yo dawg! – win this all the way through. (Plus: she has legs that could save the world.)


If I would compare this year’s bunch of aspirants to last year’s, I’d say Season 11 was better. Not that I’m insinuating that Angela and the others are not good (because they are), but collectively, the peeps from last year are way better and more entertaining. This year lacks diversity: the contestants almost have the same genre and same tone, like when you listen to them and close your eyes, you wouldn’t be able to distinguish who from who. Unlike Phillip Phillips time, they have their signature voice; they had singers for jazz, acoustic, rock, pop, country and everything else. This year doesn’t.

I just hope whoever – yo, yo dawg! – wins this thing is the most deserving. We don’t want a flop, right?

← older / top / newer →
a woeful & chaotic diary since 071409