American Idol Aftermath
Tuesday, May 29, 2012 @ 3:01 PM | 0 comment(s)

To most Filipinos, this season of American Idol had the most tuned-in and interesting and infuriating and frustrating finale ever. Everyone had been so hopeful that the 16-year-old, half-Filipino, half-Mexican contestant named Jessica Sanchez would win, given her amazing vocal chops and… amazing vocal chops. And of course, every Filipino wanted her to win because she’s a Filipino! When a Filipino joins an international singing competition, he should win because he’s a Filipino! He is the best singer in that show because he’s a Filipino! His competition would stand pale next to him because he’s a Filipino! And when that Filipino doesn’t win, well, this show sucks and/or a manipulation must have happened. How can a Filipino not win? God, this show really sucks.

Hello, us. Hello, Filipino mentality.


I’ve tuned in to American Idol for almost five years, beginning season 7. I’ve witnessed three Filipinos made it to the live shows: two got eliminated halfway of the competition (i.e.Ramiele Malubay and Thia Megia) and the last one almost won. She was almost there – she almost raised the flag to the top. Only, it stopped a shy away. Sucks for us, really.

Sucks more for the Idol winner.


I know I shouldn’t be writing about singing competitions and the hoolahs that come with it – and especially, I don’t get to say who should win and who should not because I am not a singer and I’m basically tone deaf. But this is American Idol (and not Filipino Idol), even if I don’t live in either of the fifty glorious states that gets to vote, there’s this television trend called “match airing” where the networks can air a show within hours after it was shown in America (or somewhere) via satellite. It’s pathetic, really, how I get hooked to this show even if I can’t contribute to an Idol hopeful’s destiny. But then I’m pathetic; we are all pathetic.


Getting hooked to this show and rooting for a particular contestant and hopelessly crossing fingers to make sure he/she doesn’t get eliminated are some of the reasons why we ultimately hate the show after the finale and our rooted contestant doesn’t win. These are also the reasons why we hate not only the show, but also the Idol winner. See? It sucks more for him/her.

This is the perfect time for me to insert the undying line, “You cannot please everybody”. It annoys me how people (majority of us, Filipinos) keep pushing that Jessica should have won and not the white guy with the guitar named Phillip Phillips. If you can recall, when a result has been announced, it can’t ever be taken back (this only happens in The Bachelor). And if you can also recall, this show is based on votes: the person with the most votes wins. This means we can’t put the blame on either Phillip Phillips or the show. You know who to put the blame to? The voters who tirelessly voted for Phillip to win. But then you can’t really blame them for not going gaga over Jessica – it’s their choice.

So if we just please stop sending hate mails to them? Could we please stop saying that America got it wrong, that Jessica is better than Phillip and that she should have won, that American Idol sucks and such a cheater (because it really isn’t)? What can your rants do, really? It’s not like American Idol would undo everything and alter the results. If you believe that the contestant with the biggest voice and most number of standing ovation should win, Joshua Ledet shouldn’t have been eliminated, knocked everyone down and simply took over the competition… and so is Adam Lambert or Jacob Lusk

And what’s up with the “American Idol shouldn’t be named American Idol – it should be White Guys With Guitars Idol”. So what if there’s a male trend in Idol? It can be called as a mere coincidence… or that Americans just love laidback performers better. So maybe, umm, stop posting posters online of “How To Win in American Idol: 1) Must be a white guy; 2) Must know how to play guitar; 3) Must look good; 4) Must have the “underdog aura”; 5) Must basically be charismatic”. That’s just plain pathetic and bitter.


In a lighter mood, I rooted for this particular awesome guy named Colton Dixon. (My early favorites list.) I am basically in love with him, to be simple. I swear I always prayed and believed that he would win… only he didn’t. He got eliminated, placing 7th in the competition. It was heartbreaking, so heartbreaking I cried when he sang his last song, and asked my mom to stop watching the replays. I called it “my first American Idol heartbreak”. After that I barely watched the show (I only saw it again when he performed on the finale). I didn’t hate America for not voting for my guy; I didn’t hate American Idol for not having a second set of “save” for him. I just stopped watching the show because, honestly, he was the only one whom my attention was given to. After watching his performance from the first week of the live shows, I basically turn off the television, collapse on my bunk, fangirl and log in to Tumblr the next day to reblog photos of his performance. You can say it was biased, but really, err… okay, it was biased. When he got eliminated, I still kept track of his career. I’ve learned that he worked a little with Lifehouse, got invited to a ball in White House, met several famous artists along the way, got a photo with the wax replica of Marilyn Monroe, and went back to his town, Murfreesboro, Tennessee, to write his songs. To write his songs. To write his songs for his first solo album. His first solo album. And in that moment, my prayers were answered: he won.

This story is just one of the many evidences that an Idol hopeful’s career won’t stop even if he doesn’t win. The life after the competition is just the start. If he is really good, he would make it far. And having an Idol title isn’t basically necessary. Of course, it is important, but what’s more important is the passion an artist has to chase his dreams of winning a recording contract and having a platinum album.


So, American Idol winner or not, Jessica Sanchez will make it big. And so will Phillip Phillips and everyone else from the competition – it’s just a matter of perseverance and hard work, really. Can we now all move on and hug each other?

← older / top / newer →
a woeful & chaotic diary since 071409